The Great Christmas Ornament Showdown | Best POD Ornaments Reviewed

If you sell personalized products, ornaments are the holiday classic you can’t skip. They’re small, emotional, easy to customize, and perfect for seasonal sales.
That’s why we decided to put them to the ultimate test with The Great Christmas Ornament Showdown, a 4-episode YouTube series where we review and compare ornaments from Customily’s top Print-on-Demand partners.

We ordered all the ornaments ourselves, tested their print quality, materials, packaging, and delivery times... and shared the results live!
Find our videos below and find out which ornament is the perfect fit for your store this holiday season! 🎄

The Great Christmas Ornament Showdown: Which POD Partner Shines the Brightest?

🎥 Episode 1: Acrylic, Plastic & Glass Ornaments

Our first episode kicks off with sparkle and shine! ✨ We tested acrylic, plastic, and glass ornaments from six top Print-on-Demand partners to see which ones stand out for their quality, speed, and price.Whether you want something sleek and modern or elegant and classic, these options cover every style.

ShineOn — Acrylic Ornament

• Material: Acrylic
• Shapes: Circle, Heart, Paw, Star, Tree
• Printing: One-sided
• Base cost: From $10.00
• Production time: Ships in 3–5 days
• Shipping from: USA
• Order timeline: Ordered Aug 26 → Received Sept 2
• Our take: Exclusive new shapes make ShineOn’s ornament collection a must-watch. Great for sellers focused on emotional, gift-driven products.

Gooten — Plastic Ornament

• Material: Plastic
• Shape: Circle
• Printing: One-sided
• Base cost: From $12.40
• Production time: Average 0–6 days
• Shipping: USA / 2–12 days depending on priority
• Order timeline: Ordered Aug 26 → Received Sept 11
• Our take: Light and easy to handle, Gooten’s version offers flexibility but takes a bit longer in transit.

merchOne — Snowflake Ornament

• Material: Plastic
• Shape: Unique snowflake
• Printing: Two-sided
• Base cost: From $7.00
• Production time: Ships in 2–5 days
• Shipping: USA + Europe
• Order timeline: Ordered Aug 26 → Received Sept 10
• Our take: The intricate snowflake shape and double-sided printing give it a premium, festive feel — perfect for upselling sets.

merchOne — Bauble Ornament

• Material: Plastic
• Shape: Classic bauble
• Printing: Two-sided
• Base cost: From $8.00
• Production time: Ships in 2–5 days
• Shipping: USA + Europe
• Order timeline: Ordered Aug 26 → Received Sept 10
• Our take: Traditional design meets reliable quality — ideal for stores that want a familiar Christmas look with a modern finish.

Printful — Acrylic Ornament

• Material: Acrylic
• Shapes: Rectangle, Scalloped, Circle, Heart
• Printing: One-sided
• Base cost: From $7.65
• Production time: Ships in 8–11 days
• Shipping: USA only
• Order timeline: Ordered Aug 22 → Received Sept 2
• Our take: Great print quality and clean shapes. Slightly longer production time, but reliable fulfillment and consistency.

Printify — Glass Ornament

• Material: Glass
• Shape: Circle
• Printing: One-sided
• Base cost: From $16.10
• Production time: Average 3.2 days
• Shipping: USA
• Order timeline: Ordered Aug 22 → Received Aug 30
• Our take: The only glass option in this batch — beautiful shine and premium feel, perfect for high-end stores.

🎥 Episode 2: Ceramic Ornaments

Ceramic ornaments are Christmas classics, glossy, timeless, and full of charm. 🎄In this episode, we tested some of the most popular ceramic options from different POD providers to find the best combination of quality, print detail, and turnaround time.

JetPrint — Ceramic Ornament

• Material: Ceramic
• Shapes: Circle, Heart, Tree, Oval, Star
• Printing: Two-sided (same design on both sides)
• Base cost: From $3.50
• Production time: Average 3–5 days
• Shipping: USA
• Order timeline: Ordered Aug 26 → Received Sept 11
• Our take: Great range of shapes at a low cost. Simple but effective for sellers who want fast production and solid results.

Gearment — Ceramic Ornament

• Material: Ceramic
• Shapes: Circle, Heart, Oval, Star
• Printing: Two-sided
• Base cost: From $3.75
• Production time: Not specified
• Shipping: USA
• Order timeline: Ordered Aug 28
• Our take: Competitive pricing and a clean finish. Reliable for US sellers, though delivery times can vary.

BurgerPrints — Ceramic Ornament

• Material: Ceramic
• Shapes: Circle, Heart, Oval, Star
• Printing: Available in one or two sides
• Base cost: From $3.75
• Production time: Average 2 days
• Shipping: USA
• Order timeline: Ordered Aug 26 → Received Sept 10
• Our take: Bright, detailed printing and super-fast turnaround — an excellent choice for last-minute orders.

Printful — Ceramic Ornament

• Material: Ceramic
• Shapes: Circle, Heart, Star, Snowflake
• Printing: One-sided
• Base cost: From $6.03
• Production time: Average 6–9 days
• Shipping: USA
• Order timeline: Ordered Aug 25 → Received Aug 30
• Our take: Beautiful gloss finish and strong color fidelity. Slightly higher cost, but dependable fulfillment and polished presentation.

🎥 Episode 3: Metal & Aluminum Ornaments

If you’re looking for ornaments that last beyond a single holiday season, metal and aluminum are the way to go. 🧲
They’re lightweight, durable, and have a clean, modern look that customers love. In this episode, we reviewed metallic ornaments from six Print-on-Demand providers to see which one offers the best combination of design options, print quality, and fulfillment speed.

teelaunch — Aluminum Ornament

• Material: Aluminum
• Shapes: Square, Medallion, Scalloped
• Printing: One-sided
• Base cost: From $3.75
• Production time: Ships in 3–6 days
• Shipping: USA
• Order timeline: Ordered Aug 28 → Received Sept 8
• Our take: Consistent print results and great value for money. A solid, reliable option for US-based stores.

BurgerPrints — Aluminum Ornament

• Material: Aluminum
• Shapes: Medallion, Circle
• Printing: One- or two-sided
• Base cost: From $3.75
• Production time: Average 2 days
• Shipping: USA
• Order timeline: Ordered Aug 26 → Received Sept 10
• Our take: Great balance between price and speed. Vibrant color reproduction and sturdy material make it a strong choice for sellers on tight deadlines.

JetPrint — Aluminum Ornament

• Material: Aluminum
• Shapes: Square, Circle, Star, Heart
• Printing: Two-sided (same design on both sides)
• Base cost: From $1.50
• Production time: Average 3–5 days
• Shipping: USA
• Order timeline: Ordered Aug 26 → Received Sept 11
• Our take: Extremely affordable and offers multiple shape options. A great pick for budget-conscious sellers experimenting with metal ornaments.

Printify — Aluminum Ornament

• Material: Aluminum
• Shapes: Square, Scalloped Corner, Medallion
• Printing: One-sided
• Base cost: From $7.25
• Production time: Average 1.3 days
• Shipping: USA
• Order timeline: Ordered Aug 25 → Received Aug 28
• Our take: Premium feel with fast turnaround times. Excellent for sellers who prioritize speed and quality control.

Gooten — Aluminum Ornament

• Material: Aluminum
• Shapes: 13 available (Tree, Paw, House, Circle, Fancy Mirror, Oval, Benelux, and more)
• Printing: One- or two-sided
• Base cost: From $5.40
• Production time: Average 0–6 days
• Shipping: USA (2–12 days depending on priority)
• Order timeline: Ordered Aug 26 → Received Sept 16
• Our take: Impressive shape variety makes it a creative standout. Great for sellers who want flexibility and customization depth.

BONUS: Printify — Pewter Ornament

• Material: High-quality pewter (metal)
• Shape: Unique snowflake
• Printing: One-sided
• Base cost: From $10.00
• Production time: Average 1.7 days
• Shipping: USA
• Order timeline: Ordered Aug 26 → Received Aug 30
• Our take: Luxurious, weighty feel and elegant look. The pewter finish makes it ideal for premium gift collections.

🎥 Episode 4: Bonus Track

We couldn’t finish the Great Ornament Showdown without exploring some extra-special materials that bring something different to the table, from wooden textures to high-gloss finishes that pop under the Christmas lights. ✨

This episode wraps up the entire series with a look at alternative ornaments you can add to your catalog, plus our final verdict on which Print-on-Demand partners truly shined the brightest this season.

ShineOn — High-Gloss Ornament

• Material: High-gloss finish
• Shapes: Heart, Star, Oval
• Printing: One-sided
• Base cost: From $7.50
• Production time: Ships in 3–5 days
• Shipping: USA
• Order timeline: Ordered Aug 26 → Received Sept 5
• Our take: Sleek, premium look with vivid print detail. Ideal for sellers who want a polished, elegant finish in their product line.

CustomCat — High-Gloss Ornament

• Material: High-gloss finish
• Shapes: Heart, Star, Oval, Circle
• Printing: One-sided
• Base cost: From $5.75
• Production time: Ships in 1–3 days
• Shipping: USA
• Order timeline: Ordered Aug 26 → Received Sept 5
• Our take: Great price-to-quality ratio and ultra-fast fulfillment make CustomCat a fantastic option for last-minute sellers.

JetPrint — Wooden Ornament

• Material: Wood
• Shapes: Gift Box, Sock, Bell, Circle, Tree
• Printing: Two-sided
• Base cost: From $2.00
• Production time: Average 5–7 days
• Shipping: USA
• Order timeline: Ordered Aug 26 → Received Sept 11
• Our take: Natural texture and earthy tone add a rustic touch. Perfect for eco-friendly brands or handmade-style collections.

🏅 The Final Verdict

After reviewing more than a dozen ornaments across materials, shapes, and price points, one thing became crystal clear: every Print-on-Demand provider brings something valuable to the table. Instead of a single “winner,” what we found is a set of strengths that can help every type of seller succeed:

• ShineOn impressed with its upcoming exclusive shapes and polished acrylic finishes, ideal for emotional, gift-driven designs.
• merchOne offered some of the most creative shapes in both plastic and metal, plus consistent two-sided printing.
• Gooten stood out for variety, giving sellers access to one of the widest shape catalogs in the metal category.
• JetPrint surprised us with unbeatable pricing, fast production, and a rich selection of ceramics and aluminum ornaments.
• Printify delivered premium finishes, especially with its glass and pewter pieces, making it perfect for higher-end holiday catalogs.
• Printful brought reliability and polished quality, particularly with both acrylic and ceramic designs.
• BurgerPrints delivered fast production, vibrant colors, and excellent value across multiple materials.
• CustomCat offered the fastest fulfillment in the high-gloss category, a lifesaver during peak Q4 demand.
• teelaunch provided solid, dependable aluminum ornaments with clean prints and great US coverage.

In short, there is no single “best” POD provider, just the best match for your brand’s style, audience, and pricing strategy.

And the best part? You can personalize every single one of these ornaments using Customily.
From live previews and AI mockups to ready-to-print production files, Customily connects seamlessly with all major POD partners, allowing you to sell any style, shape, or material without changing your workflow.

Beautiful ornaments, automatic personalization, and endless creative possibilities, that’s the true holiday magic 🎄✨

‍Explore all our Print-on-Demand partners here! 🎄‍